VIEWPOINT

ViewPoint is the place where you can share your thoughts on any aspect of Okanagan Life Magazine and related publications. We'd like to hear your opinions on the stories we print, what we're doing well and what we could be doing better. Use our online form to email us your comments. So sound off and check back often as we create a dynamic conversation with you and the rest of our great Okanagan community.

MOST RECENT FEEDBACK:

Power of the Written Word
Editor's Note: Our story Tick, Tick, Tick on Lyme disease was published in the magazine and posted on our website in April 2009. It's great to see the reach of the printed word as it continues to carry its message indefinitely. Today I received the following email from a reader.

Many thanks for the informative article that I just found online. My daughter, 17, has Lyme...still undiagnosied in BC. $100 grand spent to date.
Her blog: www.bitemeback.blogspot.com/
She writes a powerful, often poignant blog about her journey with Lyme disease. She is in a wheelchair and has a one minute short term memory...yes that's right. But she is an amazing, persevering young woman. Brave and outspoken about the disaster of Lyme disease in Canada.
Thanks so much,
Nicole's Mom, Chris – August 9, 2010

Happy Reader – Trail Query
What a great magazine! Iove all your articles Kudo's to the magazine. In the current issue June 2010, Farewell to Peaches and Beaches, on page 21 there is a picute of a couple
on a walking trail. Please, could you tell me where this trail is. Thanks.
Sue – June 28, 2010

Editor's Note: The trail is on Knox Mountain in Kelowna.

Funtastic Follow-up
I believe everyone in the community received their copy of Okanagan Life yesterday.
At the Spirit Square official opening, Okanagan Life floated throughout the crowd with page 10 opened up – everyone from our Mayor to Economic Development folks, communications people... pretty much all of city hall. At our board meeting last night board members brought in their copy... Thank you and Bruce (Kemp) for the piece and the coverage within the Sport Tourism section (of the article Farewell to Peaches & Beaches? – June, 2010).
Jim McEwan, Executive Director, Funtastic – June 23, 2010

Farm Fresh City Style
I wish to correct an error in Farm Fresh City Style. The author misinterpreted a response and concluded that the Penticton Community Gardens once "belonged" to me. I wish! In
reality the site is and, as far as I know, always was City property.
Thanks for an otherwise excellent article.
Carol Allen, President, Penticton Community Gardens – June 2, 2010

Congrats to Cats Without Hats
Wanted to thank Okanagan Life magazine for featuring us (Mount Boucherie Secondary School jazz combo Cats Without Hats) in the January/February issue as Charity of Choice. We appreciate your support and help in getting our fundraising goals out to the community and are happy to tell you we made it to National MusicFest in Ottawa and received the top gold standard for our adjudicated performance.
Thanks again,
Tim Hirtz – May 31, 2010

Best Restaurants Tip
Just read your excellant magazine Okanagan Life! Read all the resturant reviews. Do you realize what a market you are missing by not including things like "They offer GFGluten Free" choices. Example. Cosy Bay in Summerland has GF fish & chipes and even GF beer available.
I publish in June each year for our celiac members, locations of places to eat and shop. Our area encompasses Hope to AB border USA border to Salmon Arm.
With an estimate of 1 in 133 that are celiacs, we are a large market!
Marie Ablett, Publishing editor of Kelowna chapter of the Canadian Celiac Association
May 29, 2010

Olympic Volunteers
I really enjoyed the wonderful Olympic photo's in the April issue of Okanagan Life.  As I was a volunteer – an event services host at the Vancouver Athletes Village – I had more than my fair share of the "magic" that happened and will carry the many memories with me for the rest of my life.  
I was, however, a little disappointed that there were virtually no photo's of us!  I mean, we were everywhere doing everything!  We, along with the security employees, had so many of our own stories that have never been told.  I would suggest that someone talk to the folks who worked security at Whistler.  That was a real "eye-opener" and nobody knows the things that went on.  And, while I wouldn't have changed anything, there is a whole other side to the Olympic organization that you don't see unless you get involved.
So, great piece...but there's more to the story.
Mark Conlin, West Kelowna – May 18, 2010

Kudos for Portuguese Mosaic
I loved Portia Preigert's article (April 2010, Mosaic). I liked a lot the way you integrated the history of the Portuguese in Canada and in the Okanagan Valley, plus folklore, cuisine, etc. Great article...Our "mosaic" is richer now...Job well done. Congratulations.
Carlos Teixeira – April 25, 2010
 
PS I liked a lot the way you integrated the history of the Portuguese in Canada and in the OV...+ folklore, cuisine, etc.
GREAT article...Our "mosaic" is richer now...

Mosaic Error
I got an opportunity to go through the magazine (March 2010) for the first time and found an article on page 17 under the heading Mosaic, Religion (Spicing Up the Valley). I am a PhD Engineering student of UBCO from India. The photograph of the temple printed is not at all of Golden Temple, Amritsir, Punjab. It is not at all related to Sikh religion and is a Buddhist temple, which has all idols of God Buddha. It may be related to Jain religion, but not at all to Sikh religion. Normally it is considered to be an offence producing wrong information related to any religion.
Atul Porwal - March 22, 2010

Editor's Note: We first learned of this regrettable error through a phone call from Paramjit (Philip) Patara, president of the Sikh temple on Rutland Road in Kelowna. Mr. Patara was very gracious in accepting our sincere apology for the mistake. We immediately published a notice on this site, which is repeated below.
Mosaic Error - Our Apologies
We very much regret the error that was made in a photo and caption in the Spicing Up the Valley story in our new Mosaic column, published in the March issue. There was confusion over the name Golden Temple. We mistakenly selected a photo of the Golden Temple in Kushalnagar (a Buddhist temple) rather than the Golden Temple in Amritsar (a Sikh temple). We extend our apologies to the Sikh community of the Okanagan for our mistake.

Cougar Warning
One thing not mentioned in your article (Love@FirstType, March 2010), is sites for so called cougars. I recently was the victim of an internet dating scam, meeting the "guy" on a cougar site. Have since learned that these are the sites targeted. It would seem since there is a cougar scene in Kelowna, it would have been good to discuss this type of dating/relationship phenomena.
Elizabeth, March 18, 2010

Reader Gets "Sirius" Too
Please let Alan Sherbinin know he is so right! (Get Sirius, March 2010)
It is not usually little dogs that are discriminated against, always the big dogs.
The first time I ever saw someone bring a little dog into a store was the post office in the mission. An elderly gentlemen brought in some scraggy little thing that ended up taking a dump on the post office counter! He did nothing, the young girl behind the counter did nothing…………hello this is not time for shock………get it cleaned up! I finally said something as I was so disgusted….the young girl ended up cleaning it up with paper towel, I told her to grab a brain and get some disinfectant…..the old guy still did nothing! OMG people!
Last week I emailed a hotel in Spokane that said they were dog friendly…………..the Manager emailed back saying they only let dogs 10 lbs and under stay at the hotel………so I emailed him back and said we do not stay at hotels with dogs 10 lbs and under as all they do is YAP! So there!
Kimberlie Glavin, Kelowna - March 17, 2010

Get Sirius Gets Rave
Nice to read a humour columnist who is actually funny. And punny, which is a risk but worked here. (Get Sirius, March 2010)
Richard Derksen - March 17, 2010

Mosaic Error - Our Apologies
We very much regret the error that was made in a photo and caption in the Spicing Up the Valley story in our new Mosaic column, published in the March issue. There was confusion over the name Golden Temple. We mistakenly selected a photo of the Golden Temple in Kushalnagar (a Buddhist temple) rather than the Golden Temple in Amritsar (a Sikh temple). We extend our apologies to the Sikh community of the Okanagan for our mistake.

Hockey Guys Raise Cash for Ronald MacDonald House
We have another group of great hockey enthusiasts here in Kelowna worth telling you about.
True Consulting Group, #201-591 Bernard have organized an annual tournament held in
May. Guys have fun while raising $28,000 for Ronald MacDonald House in the past
two years. Check it out this year. Call Dave Pritchard 250-801-8783
EnjoyedJan/Feb issue, thanks.
From a proud mom,
Mary Pritchard - February 3, 2010

Chamber Lauds Hockey Issue
Right before I emailed you I read the last page of what I thought to be the best Okanagan Life magazine I’ve read! Fantastic job on this issue. I love the hockey expose and really loved all the stories here. Really great job and hats off to you and your team!!
Especially with Hockey Day in Canada around the corner, from grass roots of hockey to the pros! Great inside look and well worth the read.
Sherri Paiement, Membership Coordinator, Kelowna Chamber of Commerce
January 7, 2010

Our Mistake
Our apologies to photographer Dina Kotler who took the great shot of the Candesca singers for our Editors' Choice Awards in the November/December issue. We missed the photo credit. We really are sorry, Dina. Everybody should know that's your shot.
Editorial staff - December 8, 2009

St. Andrews by the Lake Readers' Choice Reaction
I read with great interest (Nov/Dec issue) the results of this year's Reader's Choice Awards in which we have been recognized for both our golf course operations and our pro shop. We continue to work very hard as a community to make St. Andrews the best it can be and we have many exciting improvements planned for the future. On behalf of our entire community, thank you for the recognition and we invite you to come and visit us next year!
Mark Clarke, St. Andrews by the Lake - December 4, 2009

Ballet Kelowna Dancing for Joy
Just wanted to send a huge thank you for the fantastic coverage of Ballet Kelowna in your new issue (Nov/Dec 2009). It is truly an honour to be one of your Editors' Choice and the great use of the photo is so appreciated. It is going to be a great way to make people aware of what a great jewel we have in Ballet Kelowna in our own backyards!
I am going to upload a scanned version on our website.
Dorothee Birker, Kelowna - November 26, 2009

Candesca Sings Our Praises
THANK YOU so very very much for the article in the magazine (Best of the Okanagan - Nov/Dec 2009). The girls are over the moon about the publicity. The article is perfect! Thank you so so much.
Alexandra (Sandra) Babbel for Candesca - November 26, 2009

Reader Rages Re: "Rave" Teen Author Story
Your "rave" story about the 13-year-old author was interesting, but you failed to mention the money she or her parents had to front before the publishing took place. As such, your "story'" comes off as a sales pitch for Kidpub.com, which is a vanity press, pure and simple. Package two, for example, costs $100. for 10 books, package three, $170 for 20 books, etc. Any kid with cash can scribble out their favourite jokes and make a book out of it, according to the Website. So now, the kids can nag for the money to publish their stories, (as well as an electric guitar, concert tickets, a laptop, a leather coat, etc., etc)..Sometimes ignorance really can be bliss!
Gary Kines, Coldstream - November 25, 2009

Editor's Note: I'm glad you thought it was a "rave" story, because I'm keen to recognize and support the efforts of a young person in the pursuit of a writing dream. As for your comment about Kidpub.com being a vanity press, I'm afraid that the revolution in the book publishing industry, which has seen an explosive rise in self-publishing, renders that term (and its negative connotations) passé. Of course, every self-published book must be judged on its merits - as must every traditionally published book. We've covered a number of excellent self-published books in our Q&A section. And let me say, as a parent, I'd be delighted to hear kids nagging to get a book published rather than spending the same money on peer-pressured fashions or another video game. Imagine the concept, a youngster exercising her imagination, expanding her vocabulary, realizing a dream - I'd say that's something to rave about.

Gary in for another round: l concede the point you made, as a parent, to the potentially positive aspect of kids wanting to publish at an early age, albeit with the guarantee that financial backing can provide. Perhaps that 'rave' story would serve as a good segue into an article on the difference between self-publishing (paying a vanity press--an expression still used to denote publishing on your own dime when no publishing house offers to publish your work on theirs--to edit and print your book in lots of ten), and self-publishing where you handle all the production aspects and pay for print-on-demand and shop the work around to stores or hire someone like Sandhill to distribute for you.
It's a fine line, admittedly; as a freelance writer, I often toy with the idea of grovelling before potential investors for funds to start a publishing business. In a perfect world you inherit a chunk of cash or win a large lottery, then invest in your own 'great Canadian novel' yourself so you don't have to satisfy anyone else's expectations....

Another reader weighs in: I am thoroughly committed to the idea of self- publishing, providing it is well-done--properly editied, designed, printed and marketed.
In this age of hard-to-get-published, technologies are available that make this a very affordable and possibly lucrative way to go. The key is to do it right, so a person does not end up with a basement full of books.
Having been in the business of helping people successfully self-publish for 20 years, I know it can be done successfully.
It is up to the person who wants to independently publish (the new term) to do it right so they don't end up failing for the sake of vanity.
Dona Sturmanis - January 6, 2010

RearView Reaction
I just finished reading The Weeds I Grow by Deanna Kent-McDonald (October 2009) and I must tell you it was off target. Here I am at work, it's Friday so time to slow down, check facebook messages and read an article or two. You bet I work hard, but running to buy groceries at lunch? Nobody does this! Why would anyone want to be this person. Certainly not me! At 40 I manage a partner working in Alberta home every 10 - 25 days, my two teens (and their friends) who I share joint custody with, my two bonus kids who stay every 2nd weekend and of course full time work. Women such as Deanna, find it imposible to relate to us gardening, facebooking, socializing, parenting working women because they identify us with just plain non-working moms (god forbid!) Deanna really doesn't connect with the women at school because she is probably too busy making sure her hair, make-up and outfit are appropriately sexy for work. Stop being such a snob and get a pet you are not going to lose brain cells by petting a cat.

The entire view in this article is muddled and does not represent us working mom's at all. You should ask me to write an article about mom's who have kids and husbands who come home on shifts. Kids that live out of suitcases going back and forth between homes. Working mom's who know how to take care of themselves, work hard and have a sence of balance in their lives. Listen up Deanna, you make us look bad! Check out your horoscope, plan a vacation on your lunch break, and let them plan their own damn parties! Humour, you bet...more captivating (even funnier) than the "...my guilt is a whole overgrown... dandelion patch" paradigm.
Karina, Vernon - November 13, 2009

Editor's Note: We've taken Karina up on her challenge. Look for her contribution to RearView in an upcoming issue.

Coming Attractions - Homegrown Filmmakers
Thanks for the flattering write-up (feature story - October 2009). Your magazine's showcase of some of our local filmmaking talent not only provided a terrific opportunity to let our communities know about the Okanagan's fledging film industry, but also shows other aspiring filmmakers that it's possible to get their start closer to home. I was honoured to be a part of the feature.
Jim Cliffe - November 2, 2009

CRTC Crowds Marketplace, Not Walter Grey - Reader
I recently read the article (Media Tales, October 2009) in which the following was printed; "...and when former Kelowna Mayor, Walter Grey, added two more radio stations to an already busy marketplace."

To clarify, Mr. Grey did not add* *_*two*_ more radio stations; initially the CRTC was expected only to award one new license, it was the CRTC's [sudden] choice to award two licenses; one to K96.3FM which is Mr. Grey's station, and The Juice - a non-affiliated station owned by Vista. This second license was viewed as a disappointing decision by the CRTC who's decision created the "busy" marketplace, not Mr. Grey.
Brad Hansen, Sun Country Cablevision Ltd., Salmon Arm - October 26, 2009

To Our Canadian Troops – Kudos for Renaud
Great job on the article (The Right Stuff, October 2009). Dawn, you make me look good....super writing skills. I appreciate your support and efforts to promote our To Our Canadian Troops commemorative CD project.
Dennis Leclair, Kelowna - October 22, 2009

Set the Record Straight on Xeriscape
Just a couple of corrections from the Sept. 2009 mag. that I thought you'd like to have. In the excellent article on the 'green' home, on p. 38 (Colour Me Green: an (unfinished) journey to an eco-friendly home) where the writer is talking about Lisa Masini and xeriscape gardening, she says that Lisa is "the first landscape design business in the Okanagan to specialize exclusively in [xeriscaping]' I have had a xeriscape landscape design business in the South Okanagan for the past six years and while I'm delighted that Lisa's carrying on the work, she obviously isn't the first.

The other comment that isn't quite correct is that Lisa was the founder of the Okanagan Xeriscape Association. In fact, she was the co-founder, with Gwen Steele; however, Gwen was the driving force with many years experience in xeriscaping and Lisa got involved after taking a course from Gwen. We're delighted to have Lisa's young energy involved, but I guess those of us who have worked in the trenches to popularize xeriscaping when nobody paid much attention want our bit of the sun too now that it's trendy! Thanks and thanks for all the great environmentally focused articles in the magazine; very refreshing!
Eva Durance, Penticton - October 5, 2009

Flea Market Finder
We've been getting requests for the locations of the flea markets pictured in the September photo essay Flea Market Redux. For all you savvy bargain hunters, here's the lowdown. Many of the photos were taken at the Rutland flea market, by the Centennial Hall on Rutland Road. It runs from around 8am-1pm on Sundays. Other photos were shot in Osoyoos, Penticton and Enderby.

Redd Fan Raves
(Luke) You are wonderful! I look forward to your column every issue. The magazine used to be boring – now it is edgy, exciting, fun with much more information. It's a great ambassador for the Okanagan. The evolution of Okanagan Life is now representative of the Okanagan lifestyle. Hooray and keep up your great transformation and your personal insights.
Joan DeBella - September 14, 2009

Cover Chef Catches Attention
Every time we go up to visit my grandparents, my grandmother has a stack of magazines waiting for me to take home. Okanagan Life magazine is always included in that stack. She was even more thrilled to pass along the magazine recently (May 2009), when the cover featured the chef at the restaurant I work at (Bonfire Grill). Thanks so much for a great all around magazine featuring our area!
Melissa Gelowitz, West Kelowna - August 22, 2009

Redd Reader Responds
I just wanted to tell you how much I enjoyed Gravity's Illusion in this month's edition of Okanagan Life magazine. I myself have been harbouring feelings of "doom and gloom" when thinking about the lifespan of our civilization. Our culture truly seems to be a "soulless rat race." Lately this has been causing me great anxiety about my own sometimes apathetic outlook on the world. It's good to see that someone else who observes the world in this way can simultaeneously view our future in a positive light. I enjoyed your quote: "panic is the death of useful imagination." Before I go quoting your whole article, let's just leave it at this; you managed to interpret many of the things I've been feeling into written word while putting a hopeful spin on it. Good job! And thank you.
Crystal – August 5, 2009

Come on Down to the Farm
Just a comment about the article "Mom, I'm Bored." I realize it's not a complete guide to all family activity in the Okanagan, but one group of activities that has been entirely missed, are the farms. There are a lot of us and many different activities including hayrides, tours, petting zoos and more. These are found throughout the valley and costs are usually under $25 for a family of four.

Our own farm, (www.mcmillanfarms.ca) will be offering a corn maze starting in late August and in October we sell pumpkins, have a petting zoo, hayrides and lots more.
Ron & Colleen McMillan, Kelowna – July 4, 2009

Tick Tip
Thank you soooo much for Tick, Tick, Tick (April 2009). My seven-year-old daughter and myself suffer from Lyme (disease) in Kamloops, along with many others.

I do have a request to change the info regarding the size of the nymph tick. It is actually VERY small, like a poppy seed, not as large as a small grain of rice. I do not want people to think they can feel or even see them unless you are aware to watch for them. I had one and thought it was a grain of sand stuck in my skin...

Thank you for your article,
Karry Ferber, Kamloops – April 25, 2009

Kudos to Elzer for Water Story
Don Elzer is to be commended on the depth of The Source (April 2009). Great writing, thorough research, interesting data and superb photos. Pardon me for not raising a glass of Duteau Creek water, though.
Barb Mitchell, Vernon – April 23, 2009

Stopping Men's Violence
I read with interest the juxtaposition of articles on family violence and the Okanagan Foundation in your current edition (March 2009) and applaud you for keeping both issues in the public eye.

I take the opportunity to ask the same question I started asking in Victoria in the 1970s: "What programs are established to assist men to attain non-violence in their relationships?"

At the time I was involved in Ahimsa House in Victoria, provincial funding was available - through, of all sources, women's programs! Subsequently, in the Men's transition groups I started after moving to the North Okanagan, Kinsmen provided subsidies for motivated men. Now, as I understand it, all existing programs are funded by the Attorney's General, exclusively for men charged with spousal abuse.

History makes it clear that economic downturns and high unemployment correlate strongly with a rise in family violence, for obvious reasons. Perhaps it is time to revive the idea that all men are responsible for reducing the incidence of violence against women, not just those against whom charges are laid.

I would be happy to hear from men motivated to action on this and other relationship issues.
Dave Nordstrom, Salmon Arm – April 2, 2009

Kelowna City Band – Check it Out
I simply wish to say thank you to the staff of Okanagan Life and particularly Laurie Carter for the article written about me and Kelowna City Band (Mighty Music Maven, March 2008). You've really helped us in getting the word out that the band is still going strong 100+ years later. All capable musicians are always welcome!
Heather Davis, Music Director, Kelowna City Band – March 29, 2009

Reader Rebuke
In answer to the article (Shelter Me) written in your March 2009 issue regarding Nicki Love, I was appalled that you would demean a man you do not even know. My husband and family know this man "in question" and have seen nothing else but a loving, caring, responsible
husband and father. I would think that being a "professional" you would research your "stories" before "trashing" someone's reputation. SHAME ON YOU!!
Sherry Pedersen – March 25, 2009

Abused Man Speaks Out
I just wanted to point out that (Anne-Rachelle McHugh - in Shelter Me, March 2009) totally ignored males who are abused by women. As a former victim of an abusive female I can tell you this is all too real.

This abuse included being punched in the mouth, including once while driving the car down the highway with our children in the back seat. I lost control of the car and we were lucky to have not been killed or injured. Another time she grabbed the sterring wheel and tried to steer the car into a rock bluff.

She drank heavily constantly and still drinks to this day. We have been divorced for quite a few years now. The constant verbal abuse was just awful and so was the controlling behaviour. I remember going to the dentist and being told that I was no longer covered under her dental plan.

I also remember grabbing my infant son and taking him out of the house to escape her drunken abuse. It was late at night and I had nowhere to go. I drove down to the police station to get help but they were closed for the night. I had to return home and face her. I did go to al-anon for help and they did help a bit.

There are many more incidents I could relate to you, including more physical abuse and secret affairs with men, but I won`t.

My first wife's father was also a victim of female spousal abuse. Once she showed me a hole in the wall at her parents house where her mother had thrown her father into the wall. At one point she smashed a beer bottle to the side of his head and almost completely severed his ear off. It was hanging by a small piece of skin.

I have heard other terrible stories from men of female abuse over the years. Many men are too embarrassed to report it and so they suffer in silence or end the relationship. But when children are involved this is not easy.

I find it sad and troublimng that many writers ignore the fact that men get abused too and only portray women as the victims. It shows that there is still a long way to go to solve this issue. Abuse does not know gender or age. Many senior citizens get abuse too.

I wanted to ad that children too are often victims of female abuse. I once caught a young mother in a store violently striking her crying baby in the face with an open hand, leaving terrible red welts. I was appalled. I walked up to the women and told her that if she hit the child one more time like that, I would do the same to her too. That stopped her. But I should have also called the police. There are many incidents of children being abused and even killed by their mothers.

I consider abuse to be a power thing, not a gender thing.
Mark – March 18, 2009

Kudos from Okanagan Artist
It was a pleasure to read the latest issue (March 2009) of Okanagan Life as usual. Imagine my surprise and delight when I found a lovely, colour accurate photo of my painting in the opening pages of the article Never Judge A Book... (Valley Voyeur). Sarah and Jason Podollan have created a stunning home and I am very pleased that my painting is a part of it. Kudos to the photographer and to the magazine for including Okanagan art in this issue.
Theresa Heinrichs – March 18, 2009

Kickspike Comment
Amazing article on the Kickspike couple. I saw them on the (Dragon's) Den and love the story of rags to riches. They sound like a down to earth couple with the vision and drive to do good things with their success.
Larry Boyer – January 8, 2009

Wounded Soldier's Mother Speaks Out
First of all I would like to thank you for choosing to publish Dona Sturmanis' article, Call of Duty, as your feature article for the November issue of Okanagan Life magazine. It was well
written, accurate and provided the public with a bit of insight regarding the difficult journey my son Corporal Ryan Crawford has endured as a result of the serious injuries he received in an IED attack which occurred near Kandahar, Afghanistan on Dec. 12, 2005.

Ryan and a fellow soldier were the first Canadians to be seriously injured in Afghanistan during the Canadian Forces current mission and as a result there was what can only be described as a “media frenzy” for weeks after these young soldiers were brought back to
Canada and admitted to the trauma unit at the University of Alberta hospital in Edmonton. The involvement of the media and the sharing of information in relation to injured soldiers has changed significantly since that time.

The media now provides the Canadian public with very little if any information in regard to soldiers who have been injured while on duty in Afghanistan. Their names are not
released and the nature of their injuries remains unknown. The result of this lack of information is that these soldiers become invisible to the public. Without this information, Canadians are unaware of the huge impact these horrific injuries have on both the
soldiers and their family's day to day lives.

Interestingly, CTV reported this week that there have been at least 350 Canadian soldiers seriously injured in Afghanistan, many through roadside bombings or IED attacks .The wounds these bombs inflict are horrific and when they are described as “non life-
threatening” people assume that they are minor. This is absolutely not the case. These brave young warriors return home with bodies and minds that have been forever changed and to a system that is not adequately prepared to take care of even their most basic needs. Canadians have been left in the dark when it comes to recognizing the true cost of our country's involvement in war.

Although they have escaped the fate of being brought home in flag draped coffins, the injured have sacrificed flesh and blood for their country and many continue to suffer each and every day. These courageous souls deserve community recognition, emotional and
physical support and the best and most appropriate medical treatment available. Sadly it is my belief that injured soldiers are still not receiving adequate care A recently released
report by the military ombudsman has confirmed these doubts.

The article Call of Duty shares with readers a brief glimpse into my life as the mother of an injured Canadian soldier.This journey has changed my life in ways that I cannot begin to express; it has been an education as well as an ongoing and difficult struggle. I hope
that by sharing my story it will help people to undeerstand how difficult life can be for the injured when they return home.

It is my hope that as time goes on injured soldiers and their families will make the decision to share their stories. There is a significant need for awareness by the Canadian public of
the huge costs and sacrifices so many have had to endure due to our country's decision to be involved in this battlefield so far from home. It is only through understanding and awareness that clear and appropriate decisions can be made about our country's future in that situation.

Thank you so much for providing your readers and our community with this information, it is much appreciated.
Carol Williams – December 30, 2008

Hope for the Homeless
I just wanted to email you and thank you for the amazing article you wrote (November/December 2008) about Cardington (the supportive housing project recently launched in Kelowna to help homeless people get back on their feet). It is wonderful and so positive. Thanks so much.
Shelley Cook, Executive Director, John Howard Society of the Central and South Okanagan – November 24, 2008

Soulful Songstress Sings Our Praise
... just wanted to write and say a big thank you for the story in today's Okanagan Life (November/December 2008). Wow – an Editors' Choice. I'm thrilled. Thank you so
much. Also please pass on my thanks to Luke for writing the story and Lydia for the great photos. It's an honour to grace the pages of your fine magazine.
Jane Eamon – November 18, 2008

Kudos From Gallery Vertigo
A note of thanks to all who are responsible for the wonderful article in Okanagan Life magazine about Gallery Vertigo artist-run centre in Vernon. We were extremely pleased with the coverage, including the thorough and astute comments by journalist, Dona Sturmanis and the fabulous pictures by Kyle Perison.
We have received many favourable comments and interested phone calls and visits from people throughout the Okanagan as a result. Thank you very much for this excellent article!
Judith Jurica, Director, Gallery Vertigo, Vernon – November 13, 2008

Reader Connects with Redd
Dear Sir, or can I call you Luke – or perhaps you’d prefer Mr. Creative/Editorial Director,
Ah but no, you stated quite honestly and clearly in your RedRoomRamble in the September 2008 issue that you are no longer driven by your ego and pride (albeit the anger comes out occasionally which knowledge will ensure that I’ll NOT call you any offensive names!); therefore I’ll omit the formalities (despite the fact that you have absolutely no idea who I am, and I only know you by a photo that I’ve seen twice now)…
So here we are with…

Dear Luke,
I’m sure you still have some ego in that nice looking face of yours, so I don’t mind letting you know that while glancing through your magazine and being compelled to stop and read your thoughts (having read them once before in the last issue), I enjoyed the flow of your words, and admired your honesty, as well as your ability to take a good look at your motivations/beliefs and have the willingness to share them with your readers. I enjoyed your metaphor of the moat-surrounded castle; I could envision the drawbridge descending, making yourself vulnerable as you allow another the chance to share his/her beliefs with you. And every time you so, you take the risk of being attacked (because who knows how many weapons the other carries or how long he/she has been preparing for battle), thereby increasing your humility and opportunity to expand within yourself.
The analogy of the dance was also nice, showing that you are capable of opening yourself up to others and allowing them into your space – when, previously, you must’ve preferred dancing to your own tune alone.
While I am not a hot debater (not to say I don’t have my own strong opinions, in some cases), I could see some of myself in what you wrote as I take careful steps out of my own protective space, and let myself connect more with others in my life. Not many articles catch my eye, and yours did. I read it and liked it. So thank you.
Sincerely,
... Stacey..., Kelowna – October 27, 2008

Kudos to Freake for Objectivity
I have never written to a magazine before but after reading an article in your current issue I felt compelled to send you a note. The story I am referring to is: TheHottest Button. I have always believed in pro-choice and I do not see that ever changing.
When I began reading the story I thought it was going to be completely biased one way or the other. Sometimes reading this type of story can be nothing more than sad entertainment because of the general bias. I find these stories very hard to get through. Once I began reading the story I became engrossed in it. RossFreake presented the story from a very neutral place despite his personal feelings. I wish more articles were done in a manner like this. Whether or not someone agrees with the stance being taken, and I am still pro-choice, it presents the other side of the argument in a non-threatening way.
Please send my thanks to Ross Freake for doing a great job on such a difficult topic.
Eric Mummery – September 26, 2008

What About the Children
I think Marlon Bartram should spend more time looking at all the unwanted children that end up in the government's care. Due to unwanted pregnancies millions of children end up in foster care and grow up being pasted around from home to home. He claims to be a social worker, than take a deeper look into the current system!
Not to mention there are other children that stay in the homes of their unfit parents who could care less if they existed or not. These children grow up in a very hard place.
People have a right to make their own informed choices about sexual health. The main thing is educating individuals to prevent unwanted pregnancies in the first place. There are tons of safe sex options out there, lets teach people to take advantage of them.
Jessica Bonise – September 22, 2008

S@#t Hits the Fan Revisited
Editor's Note: Our editorial director, Luke Redd, personally responded to every reader who wrote us about the phrase "shit disturbers" on the cover of our September issue. As a result, Lisa Johnson replied with this message.

I just wanted to let you know that because of your response I took the magazine out of the recycling bin...and yes I am reading it – minus the front cover. The fact that you responded said a great deal to me.
I will be very interested in reading the next issue and curious about the kind of dialogue that may or may not take place after this. I appreciate that although this word may have no hateful meaning behind it, it is still a word that will get kids in trouble at home and at school (at least the younger grades), and it is frowned upon in the work place. Are there worse words that people use? Absolutely – and they are not always swear words, but seeing that "word" on the front of your magazine certainly caught me off guard.
I have now read your column in this issue, and as usual it makes me smile, and ponder things. I am looking forward to reading the rest of the magazine. I am glad that I "opened the gate to let all ideas in."...well except for the front cover...but I too jest. Thanks for taking an interest in one reader's opinion because you saved it from going unread, and that
indeed would have been quite a sad.
Lisa Johnson – September 11, 2008

Lisa's first message:
YIKES! What were you thinking? I don't know about you, but I still consider s@#! a bad word, and to see it on the front of your magazine was really discouraging. I have always enjoyed your magazine, and found the articles to be informative. This was a magazine that I could keep on the coffee table, but not this issue...I have kids in the house. Seriously if you are proud of your product, and you should be, then you do not need to use words like that to catch our attention. Why not just do what you do well and that is to write interesting articles using more acceptable words...or at least have the decency to use symbols, and not put it on
the front cover. Sadly I will not be looking through this issue, and neither will my children and that is a real shame... for the advertisers too. You have lost me as a reader for this issue, but I
am hoping your standards will return with the next.
Lisa Johnson – September 9, 2008

Kudos for Objectivity
As usual, I was about to recycle all the excess printed material my husband brings home, when your front cover (September) caught my eye. I was almost afraid to read the article,
expecting it to be the (normal) diatribe against pro-lifers. How refreshing, encouraging, amazing, that you have offered an unbiased presentation of the background and
beliefs of one passionate man. I applaud you and Ross Freake for going where (almost) no one has gone before. Marlon Bartram is also worthy of applause. Whether I believe in his
cause or not, he is well spoken, educated and committed to fighting injustice. I admire his integrity.
Valerie Garding, BScN, Winfield – September 11

Bartram Profile Provokes Protest ... In Two Parts
Message One:
I think you made a horrible editorial decision to feature Marlon Bartram in the Sept/08 issue. You know if you ignore these people they may just go away (unless you agree with him, which is even more frightening). His views are extremely dangerous for women. I noticed that John Irving's abortion novel The Cider House Rules was not on Mr. Bartram's book list. He should read it...he may learn what happens to women that don't have access to safe abortion. ... He should not have space in a magazine. This is outrageous and you should be ashamed.

Message Two:
I've done this before; I sent a note earlier and while I found the actual writing of the note a rather cathartic experience, I do regret hitting send. I hope you do not take it personally; I
harbour no ill will towards you. These were merely my views and I hope you take it as such. I also want to ensure that these comments are just between you and I. I do not wish for my
comments to be made public. I'm scared see...pro lifers have killed doctors (now there's irony for you).
R – September 9, 2008

Editor's Note: We have been in contact with R and obtained permission to publish his messages.

S@#t Hits the Fan
Editor's Note: The reference to "shit disturbers" on the cover of our September issue has produced swift reaction from some readers. Here's what they're saying.

Love your magazine - hate your caption on the cover of the Sept 08 issue - I beleive "shit" is still a swear word, isn't it? I surmise I speak for many people when I say "Come on people -
you have more class than that." Remember: Never stoop to a level where your customers have to wonder where your scruples are...
Jacqui Conroy – September 10, 2008

My family always looks forward to reading your magazine - but they won't read this issue. It's in the recycling before the kids get home from school today. Was it really necessary to use the term "Shit disturbers" on the cover? Can we not set a better example for our kids than this?? Perhaps some of your corporate advertisers should think again before they spend their marketing dollars on your magazine.
Disappointed in Vernon,
Kim – September 10, 2008

I just received a copy of your magazine for September 2008. I will not be putting it in the waiting room of the office I work in. In a society that is slowly going downhill, etiquette slowly
eroding...why would I promote your magazine by putting it on display...your title "The Crusaders: you might call them sh*t disturbers...."
You really couldn't come up with a better word to describe this? I find it appalling that you would put a blatant swear word on the cover of your magazine.
Kimberly Horie – September 9, 2008

Was it really necessary for a magazine that usually is very eloquent to use cuss words on the front page? Am I really expected to leave this on the counter of my business so one of my client's children can aspire to be a "shit disturber"? Obviously your new editor is Eminem and if I wanted rap lyrics I'd buy an x-rated album. Fire Eminem!! Hire somebody who can write...
Sandra Malko – September 9, 2008

I am absolutely appalled you would use the words "shit disturbers" on the cover of your magazine. While the article is interesting, I feel the vulgar term is not warranted. I am very offended.
Susan – September 9, 2008

Correction: Flyers NOT All Old Guys
I read your magazine (print) and really liked your articles on 'the ultimate lift' (July/August). I am an aviation enthusiast as well as work in the industry. I just wanted to point out a mistake on one article, on page 14 (High Flying Adventure - Young Eagles), which I participated in and flew roughly 25 per cent of all the flights that day. It says that Randy, at age 53, is the youngest member of the flying club, which isn't true. I happen to be younger than him, at age 36! The reason that I think this is important would be to attract younger people to our industry and hobby, from a younger persons perspective it isn't as appealing!
Lee Sorken – August 6, 2008

Who Knew – Aviator Adds Detail to Seymour/Duddle Story
Just wanted to say as an old aviator and air traffic controller how much I enjoyed your article on ultralites. Just one thing though, although Eldon Seymour and Jimmy Duddle did build the Corbin Baby Ace of the 1930's (July/August 2008, Who Knew?) they were not the first to fly it! That honour belonged to my father, the late Capt. L. L. Dunsmore (Air Canada retired 1967). If you wish I can provide you with the story of this – I gave the log books to the Vernon museam and a remarkable OK love story!
Bill Dunsmore, Vernon – August 2, 2008

Editor's Note: We did know about Capt. Dunsmore's role in the story, but with limited space, chose to focus on the teenagers, Seymour and Duddle. Thanks to Bill Dunsmore for his email highlighting this important detail.

Ramble Rates Another Rave
I've been reading your Red Room Rambe for some time now and have been meaning to let you how much I enjoy your "thoughts and life experiences." I give the cover of the magazine a cursory glance and I turn straight to your latest rambling.
You remind me very much of someone I used to work with (a little too much ... but I digress...) um ... digress ... does that go with dark chocolate and red wine?
Thanks for an eclectic and somewhat disturbed perspective on life ... food ... sex and many other topics!
If you ever decide that you would like to enjoy a juicy burger with all the fixing (I can hide the ketchup if you need that done...), give me a call and come and enjoy the North Okanagan!
Keep up the great words!
Jay, Vernon – July 23, 2008
PS – I send Okanagan Life to friends in Southern California.

Ad Placement Rankles Reader
I've just graduated high-school and  I live in Winfield.  I know that your magazine has no "Reader Comments" section, but  I've got some anyway.  Recently I've been reading and really enjoying Okanagan Life. I  especially like the articles you have about local eating and 
Okanagan development. I thoroughly enjoyed reading an excellent  article ("Do It Yourself") in your latest issue (June/July - Big Ideas), talking about the  importance of building and appreciating the process of building  your own home, but disappointed to turn the page and see yet  another advertisement for yet another development with cookie-cutter houses. I wondered if the irony had escaped you.
Katrina Boechler, Winfield – July 8, 2008

Ramble Rates Rave Review
I just finished reading your article, Just Do…Nothing (June/July) and I had to say … Remarkable!
I recently finished The God Delusion by Richard Dawkins so your article struck a note with me. It is definitely worth the read and especially great for those of us who’ve had religion jammed down our throats most of our lives!
Looking forward to reading more of you!
Marcelle Chisholm, Vernon – July 7, 2008

Pulse Immigration Story Sparks Feedback
Editor's note: In our September 2007 issue, Kevin Tucker was among the individuals we interviewed for our feature on work in the Okanagan. His experience as a new immigrant to Canada as well as the Okanagan made for some disturbing reading. Our recent story, "Immigrants Welcome?" about a UBCO symposium on Valley immigration issues sparked this message from him.

Great edition! ... I noticed informative coverage of a similar theme (immigration) from UBCO in July’s edition of OL. This topic will get no smaller over the next few years.... Keep up the high-quality articles.
Kevin Tucker – July 7, 2008

Subscriber Soured by "Negative" Content
I am a subscriber to OLM. After the last issue (June/July) I feel compelled to comment.

I look at the advertising base of your magazine - high end stuff - homes/furnishings, estate communities, BMW's, jewels - consistently the trappings of the life of the wealthy. Then I look at the tone of the magazine ... sort of counter to the goal of the advertisers and wealthy people who pick up the magazine while visiting our communities in the Okanagan.

I am an environmentalist and concerned about the issues facing our Valley and the earth, but this is presented in a very negative manner in your magazine and it isn't the content I want to see. Big Ideas is an example of the negative approach I'm speaking of. Apologizing for the lack of content due to busy schedules of people who have serious ideas isn't an acceptable way to begin the lead article and the contributors are slapping the wrist of all the Valley residents. Very counter-productive.

The last two editorials written by Luke Redd are simply bizarre (I can't remember the ones before that). This guy needs to write a personal blog to exorcise his personal demons and write some constructive stuff in your magazine.
Brian Lloyd – July 7, 2008

Big Ideas Blog Draws Thumbs Up
Editor's note: We posted the 15 Big Ideas featured in our June /July issue on Okanagan Life's blog The Futureology Exchange and drew this reaction to ideas 3 and 4.

Comment:
I love the captain post... I'm a mom. Who does everything. I'd love to be treated like I own a yacht instead of the rowboat sinking feeling I often have. Thanks for your great posts.
July 4, 2008

In Person Profile Hits the Mark
I just returned from a week on the road and received a couple of copies of Okanagan Life. I feel blessed to be included in an issue that discusses the best Okanagan eateries. Many more people will thumb through that baby rather than an edition devoted to education. "Toe-tappin', train talkin' troubadour" is inspired writing. You did a very accurate job of catching what I'm all about. Congratulations.
Jack Godwin, Lead Singer, Kettle Valley Brakemen, Naramata – June 11, 2008

Diet Story Sparks Diatribe
The article in your May issue of OK Life about the 100 Mile Diet is interesting and one would think that in a valley as lush and bountiful as ours, that local food would be easy to find, but your article painted a very different and disappointing picture.

Perhaps what was most surprising was the lack of research that went into writing it.

In particular, your reference to Nature’s Fare Markets was not only slighted against the company, but incomplete and thusly, incorrect. Nature’s Fare should, for all intensive purposes, be in a category separate from other retailers who carry local but conventional, non-organic foods as those are much easier to find. Regardless, your profile of Nature’s Fare and its stand on buying local was greatly misguided. We PRIDE ourselves in buying local first whenever possible and have outstanding relationships with local farmers, ranchers and food artisans. Every store buys from a local bakery in their area and our Apple Delis have seasonal menus with as many local ingredients as possible. Not only that, but our commissary kitchen in Vernon makes 99% of the food for all of our Delis and as such you could say we are producing our Deli food locally whereas the other stores you mentioned are carting their deli items up from Vancouver or from across the border.

It’s very disappointing to see Okanagan Life – a local magazine – tear down a local company that has built its success in harmony with local famers and the local community.

At Nature’s Fare Markets we carry numerous local products and, if anyone had bothered to ask a manager or call media relations at head office to find out more, you would have discovered that local is always our first choice.

Amongst the many local products we carry which your article failed to mention are:

Voights Coffee
Cherry Hill Coffee
Vale Farms Meat (Lumby)
Sisi Dressings (Kelowna)
Little Creek Salads & Dressings (Westbank)
Armstrong Cheeses
Bill’s Honey (Kelowna)
Busy Bee Honey (Vernon)
Suncatcher Farms (Kelowna)
Quail’s Farm (Enderby)
Sproule & Sons Family Farm
Sunshine Eggs
Sunshine Farm Seeds
Curly Willow Farms
Caramoomel Dips & Sauces
Dutchman Dairy (Summerland)
Okanagan Soy Cheese (Vernon)
Pure Basil
Joy of the Mountains
Goji Juices & Berries ….. and the list goes on.

There is much debate about local vs organic and though the best solution is local and organic, it cannot always be so. Some believe that even if something organic travels a bit further, it has still done more to serve the environment because of the soil-preserving methods used to grow that food and the lack of pollutants created & chemicals produced in growing it. Soil erosion, due to conventional farming practices, is one of the largest environmental crisis we face as a planet and no matter how local your food is, if it is grown using chemical pesticides, it contributes to this very big problem.

This letter could go on and on and if you ever wish to write about Nature’s Fare Markets again, please feel free to contact me for accurate information.

P.S. Many of the same farmers you buy from at the local Farmer’s Market, are the same Farmers we buy from in-store. Just an FYI.
Christina Erl Daniels, Marketing & Promotions Director, Nature's Fare Markets –
June 3, 2008

Editor's Note: Thank you for taking the time to write in about your concerns. Respectfully, I take issue with some of the bold statements you make, some of the products which you list and your overall comprehension of the article.

To say that the reference in the article to Nature's Fare is somehow slighted against your company is absurd. This is the kind of overstated charge that requires clear evidence. I could not find a single sentence in the article that disparages or aims to tear down your company.

Lisa Harrison, the writer of this story, merely translated her personal experience of walking into one of your stores and seeing what she could find that would be able to be included in a true 100-mile diet. It was first-hand, experiential research. In point of fact, much of what she was able to find at Nature's Fare ("There are a few cheeses, milk, eggs, dressings and honey.") match what you list in your letter and is, therefore, quite accurate. While admittedly a little vague and brief, I would hardly characterize Lisa's findings as incorrect.

I think that you are clearly overlooking the fundamental point of the article — that being a search for what one could find easily that fits the criteria of the 100-mile diet. That means that every single ingredient, even in a "local" product, must have been grown or produced within a 100-mile radius of where it is being sold.

Therefore, such products as coffee (number one and two on your local products list) would not qualify, even if the coffee beans are organic and locally roasted and packaged. Coffee is an import. Coffee berries are not grown in North America.

Ditto for salad dressings such as those from Little Creek (my favourite!). Some of the most obvious non-qualifying ingredients (based on a 100-mile diet) would include lemon juice, sea salt, rice vinegar and tamari soy sauce.

Packaging and preparing food is not the same as growing or raising it.

Okanagan Life magazine shares your passion for promoting a better understanding of, and appreciation for, local and organic food. However, the article that you see as incomplete is more clearly focused on exploring the achievability of the 100-mile diet in the Okanagan, organic or not.

I would encourage you to re-read the article for a clearer comprehension. –LR

Kudos for Slivar
We want to thank you very much for the nice article you wrote about Osoyoos Gelato in your May issue of Okanagan Life magazine. You have it all so nicely worded, really very impressive. Some customers actually brought in a copy of the article, which was kind of them. I have just taken out a subscription to OLM.
Robert Klei, Osoyoos - June 2, 2008

Okanagan Hypocrisy Riles Reader
I have just finished reading your Redroomramble forward in  this  May's issue of Okanagan Life. On many levels, its easy to relate to your stories about being a vegan, and constantly having to explain your food choices. It must  be a never-ending repetitious line of queries in regards to your  culinary habits, and for that, you certainly have my sympathies. Your comments about avoiding the monolithic Monsanto machine, and  literally "eating the rich" had me smiling.

However, there is something egregiously off-putting about reading an article which discusses global financial/social issues whilst  being sandwiched between an advertisement for Bighorn Mountain Estates and the tweed-and-jacket Pablum of Raymond  James financial  advising, which had my bile rising just a little. Perhaps, if you  truly care about some of the incredible financial challenges we  face globally and locally, that you push hard to change Okanagan  Life from an all-too-obvious advertising vehicle for predatory  land developers and faux-chic costume jewellers to a political  activist's publication.

Ok, so I jest a little as well! But here is something to chew on  (granted, as long as the morsel is free of animal matter): Kelowna,  as you may know, has metastasized into the worlds 13th most  expensive locale, when expressed as a function of average household  income versus housing price. I am a local business professional  and I make what used to be considered "good money." However, my  family and I have been essentially treated like landed serfs since  arriving here and have discovered that the very same professionals  upon whom this community relies to feed their bloat are  generally sidelined, both culturally and economically.

We are looking to leave as soon as humanly possible. Now, before your twitching fingers edit forth a rejoinder to the effect of "if  you don't like it here....then get out," consider this:
At eight per cent growth per annum (a controversial figure, but one that I shall cite nonetheless), this community NEEDS professionals like myself. I expected to be treated like any professional in any major  metro, but instead ended up being treated with the worst 
kind of  xenophobia, ignorance, and religious zealotry the likes of which I  haven't seen since living all over Western Canada for the last 12  years.

Building community means welcoming artists, professionals  and support people to build up its character and livability. All comers need be welcome, not just the rich oil-sands barons and top-slice five per cent of the baby-boomers who can afford to set up shop in a  Ridge Home @ The Outback for a bargain $1.175 million.

Your article is, I would say, a picture perfect example of the kind of magnanimous tongue-in-cheek hypocrisy that Kelowna is surely  famous for elsewhere. It's a real shame that Okanagan Life  features articles like Perspective Corrective, detailing indigenous perspectives on sustainability, or The 100-Mile Diet,  and yet continually garners its financial support from golf  courses, property developments and clothiers that are completely  out of the reach of hard-working 30-something professionals like  myself and my family.

It's both a slap in the face and a huge disincentive to stay here and contribute our much-needed tax-base to your "community."
Anonymous Businessman – May 29, 2008

Education Feature Prompts Input on Early Kindergarten
While on the subject of education...what follows is my Vancouver Sun “Sound Off” letter, Let's Stop Pushing Early Kindergarten. (Published Tuesday, March 25, 2008)

Re: Politicians debate best learning environments for kids under five, March 22

Janet Steffenhagen reports "there is no consensus about a supplementary promise by government to consider extending kindergarten to four-year-olds by 2010 and three-year-olds by 2012."

When did education in British Columbia become a race? It's bad enough that some are advocating all-day kindergarten for five-year-olds, let alone consider extending kindergarten to four and three-year olds. What are these people thinking?

I had the privilege of hearing Australian psychologist Steve Biddulph at last October's Gender and Student Achievement conference in Kamloops. According to Biddulph, all-day kindergarten is too long, and any younger is a mistake developmentally.

Recently, a major review of British primary schools by Cambridge University was made public. In one report from the National Foundation for Educational Research, the practice of allowing children to start school at age four was found to be stressful.

Yet authors Anna Riggall and Caroline Sharp found that in some countries where students start school up to two years later, many outperform their English peers. The authors concluded:

"While the value of high-quality pre-school education is beyond dispute, the assumption that an early primary school starting age is beneficial for children's later attainment is not well supported by the research evidence."

Biddulph says the calendar is a poor guide for when a child should start school. Decades of research has shown that most boys (and some girls) are slower to develop fine-motor and language skills. I'm wondering how many of these children would benefit from an additional year in kindergarten -- "senior kindergarten." They could begin Grade 1 at age seven, when their fine-motor skills are ready for pencil-and-paper work.

Educators in several European countries such as Sweden, Denmark and Finland have promoted this idea for years, and it has paid off not only in happier children, but also in terms of academic success and far fewer dropouts.

I would like to encourage a grassroots movement of parents, teachers and school board officials throughout the province to begin a dialogue with the ministry of education to see if a pilot program for the 2008-09 school year could be implemented in which one or more elementary schools in each district could receive special funding for the creation of senior kindergarten classes.
David Buckna, Kelowna - April 30, 2008

Carter Gets Creamed
I don't usually read Okanagan Life magazine, but as a  teacher your April 2008 cover  story caught my eye. While  the entire issue is far too complicated to be addressed by one article, I agree it is  worth considering. I found  your tone, however, fairly  disrespectful, especially to  those so-called people (I infer you mean the young people) who send in story  pitches only to be at the  receiving end of your  department's scorn and  ridicule. In light of that, I find it  ironic, and yes humourous,  that your story contains, in  bold blue type on page 43, a  spelling error. You  write, "Salary averages are effected by a variety of  factors. . .". I believe you should have  used the word AFFECTED  (affect being a verb), as  EFFECTED  (effect is a noun)  does not work in this sentence.  As an aside, I am not sure  why you even included the  salary graph in the piece, since you do not directly  speak to teachers' salaries. What is your point exactly? But back to your grammatical  faux-pas. To use your own  words, "call me unreasonable,  but I have a certain  expectation that the people  who want to be paid for  putting words to page should  be able to demonstrate some  facility with the written  language." Oops.  I promise not to  laugh.  That would be mean.
Laurelle Larmand – April 28, 2008

Editor's Note: Thanks so much for taking the time to write. A couple of points … I'm not sure what you mean by your reference to "so-called" people. I can't find anything in the story that suggests the writers who send in story ideas are anything but people … a bit confusing.

As for your catch on affected/effected, first you refer to this as a spelling error then later as a grammatical error. It was not a spelling error – "e" mistakenly used instead of "a" (I wish it had been). You are absolutely right in your conclusion that it was a grammatical faux pas (no hyphen – it’s so easy to make one little slip. What gets me is the pitch letters with three and four errors in every paragraph). The affect/effect mistake is one of the most common in the English language – and we missed it. I'm really glad you read the story closely enough to find it and greatly appreciate you taking the time to point it out to us.

Footnote: No wonder affect and effect cause us so much trouble. As you state – affect is a noun and effect is a verb. But it happens that affect is also a verb and effect is also a noun. Both words have noun and verb forms. English – what a language! –LC

Kudos to Sturmanis:
Sunshine Tax Story a Must-Read for Recruiters and Job Seekers
I spoke with Dona Sturmanis when she was writing her article The New "Sunshine Tax" for your latest 2008 edition (Okanagan Life Progress). This is an excellent article and because we work with both unemployed job seekers and employers looking to fill job vacancies this article is particularly valuable to us....(We would like to) distribute it to all of our Okanagan and Shuswap staff.
Christine Bowman, Bowman Employment - March 4, 2008

Reader Joins Fisticuffs on Gravel Pits:
Connects Argument with Redd's Ramble
It is wonderful to have the Creative/Editorial Director of Okanagan Life speak out. However, on this topic your job was easy – no creativity was needed:  it is as you say it is.
You are right – God won’t help us, the space aliens are staying away and the government (at all levels) is at the Mad Hatter’s tea party.

Our own little microcosm, the Okanagan Valley, is a Titanic. With the historic record and all previously garnered knowledge ignored, we are steaming ahead towards the same fate. We won’t founder on icebergs though, we’ll founder on rocks as the lake level drops.

Seriously, your Sandbox contributor Steve Dimond has a very one-sided view – the straight road all the way to the bank: “Truck traffic, dust and noise and a changing visual landscape are the most obvious detractions from aggregate operations,” he says. So, let us take Mr. Byron Dafoe’s plan to operate a gravel pit at the end of Lakeshore Road as an example. Trucks? Along Lakeshore Road. Last August there was a gravel truck accident at a relatively straight section of the road. Just imagine the accident potential with daily traffic of 30 full and 30 empty trucks (minimum) on our rural, hilly, twisting, residential road with school buses, cyclists, vineyard visitor and park visitor traffic. Dust? We see the dust rising from various gravel pits – hardly scenic fare for the beautiful Okanagan!  The hazards carried on dust from Okanagan pits are well known. With the prevailing winds, dust from Mr. Dafoe’s pit would be blown over the Kettle Valley community and dust from the trucks would contaminate all families living along Lakeshore Road. The ways to reduce and control dust as described by Mr. Dimond are not inscribed in the present permit requirements – they cost money. There would be no enforcement – they just would not be criteria. The dust kicked up along the highway and blowing from trucks would be detrimental to those with respiratory problems, to the young, to the old.

No one’s health should be placed in jeopardy for one man’s personal gain and for the benefit of people who have yet to move into the area. Not mentioned are fumes from trucks’ exhaust, which foul the air and which are toxic to all forms of life! Noise? Heavy traffic noise throughout the day – like living near an express highway. Remember, this is Lakeshore Road  in the Mission! Where is the “compatibility”  Mr. Dimond speaks of in the first paragraph of his argument?

As Mr. Dimond states “nature dictates where gravel sources lie” and there are lots of locations not too distant from Kelowna which harbor gravel sources. It is Mr. Dimond who decides which gravel source lies in what he terms “the ideal location” and that, again, is dictated by lust for financial gain.   

What is so remarkable is that, for about a year now, the Dafoe pit, Eagle Mountain Developments, is still on the table. It lies within the confines of a Provincial Park, yet Parks appear to have nothing to say against having a gravel pit despoil and scar its landscape. This gravel pit would despoil park habitat, which has already been devastated by the 2003 fire and is struggling to regain a healthy vigour. This gravel pit (notwithstanding berms and such devices) would cripple any spawning, which occurs in Deeper Creek. Environment does not see fit to step in to protect the creek. The road leading to the gravel pit is unfit for the projected traffic and yet Transport hasn’t stepped in – in fact Transport is constructing a new bridge across Deeper Creek at Mr. Dafoe’s request. To be fair, the existing bridge was in much need of repair. And, while 95 per cent of the people who live along Lakeshore Road live in Kelowna, the municipality has no control whatsoever over something that might so adversely affect the lives of its citizens. Where is the government? What can people do to protect their rights? Their rights should be protected by those elected to office.

The awarding or not awarding of mining permits is in the hands of Mr. Krueger, the Minister of State for Mines. Mr. Krueger has been sitting on his hands for nearly a year. He has been through the area and seen what is involved.  Lakeshore Road is now lined with large signs saying: No Gravel Pit on Lakeshore Road. The message is clear –

Mr. Dafoe would do well to listen to the advice given in the last paragraph of your article “It’s time for each of us to accept personal responsibility for what amounts to defecating in our own Froot Loops.”
Gillian Barany, Kelowna – February 8, 2008

Reader Mourns Penticton Tree Trashing
I would like to thank Karen Wilson for  her Rearview, Pine Beetle Paranoia. Her words touch my heart and reflect only too sadly the situation here in Penticton after the storm in  November.
There has been an all out  assault on perfectly healthy native mature trees. Our town is naked and barren. The loss of bird habitat is shocking as well as the increased  exposure to sun and wind by removing native trees best suited to our Okanagan climate is devastating.
I  too hid in my room and was unable to  venture out on foot in my neighborhood  for eight weeks following the storm without  fearing another chain saw. I cringed  every time I saw the Cotters tree removal truck go past my house, wondering whose trees were next. I too was questioning my role and  responsibility, I tried speaking with some neighbours about the advantages of  keeping native trees and was met with indignation and accusations. So I  withdraw from the insanity and wonder  why we are so removed from the natural  environment that supports us.
Trees that are a part of the ecosystem that gives us and other creatures life, several hundred years old removed in case they fall on a house that may take one week to repair?  Where is the "lifestyle" we all moved here, or stay here, for?
I am so pleased with the message of  the magazine this month, drawing awareness to the issues we are facing but seemingly oblivious to in this so precious valley I have called home for  the past 26 years after moving around the world for 20 years. Please, we need more of these issues, not to turn into doom and gloom, but  informative and educational the way  this issue is.  MANY THANKS.
Michelle Parry, Penticton – February 2, 2008

Quest Model Misses the Boat on Water Issues
Interesting multi-faceted discussion...
Which of the participants has a working understanding from on-the-ground, real-world work in the Okanagan basin watersheds, of fish & wild life conservation issues.
The Quest model does not account for people who are transients ie: tourists and/or visitors and/or recreationists, who's impacts  place substantial demands on the Okanagan basin resources, but have little or no commitment to its sustainability.
The Quest model also doesn't adequately account for the other transients mentioned by your panel, namely people who live here only part of the year and who also have little commitment to the basin's sustainability.
I recall asking Tourism Kelowna for statistics on the numbers of tourists/visitors, after attending a Quest model session. They said that in 2006 there were over 1 million "person nights" for Kelowna. But they couldn't tell me about the other parts of the basin, because those figures are scattered and unaggregated.
So in a sense in some respects we are flying blind and the Quest model's results are suspect, without adequate sensitivity testing.
It's nice to have rosy pictures/visions/dreams/scenarios about what the Okanagan basin might look like in the future.
As a a former operations research analyst, and now a businessman with an admitted passion for fish, I'm trained to find root causes of certain problems...here I keep coming back to water (surface & sub-surface) as being a key limiting factor to growth - also unaccounted for by the Quest model.
The view of many people is that 'you have to measure it to manage it'...hence an effort by OBWB (Okanagan Basin Water Board) to develop a hydrometric monitoring network for the valley...a bit long overdue I'd say. Perhaps, the OBWB water budget project, if ever completed, will shed additional light on the role water will play here. The results might be illuminating.
There are examples of other parts of the world with similar bio-geoclimatic conditions and problems...who we could perhaps, learn from, eclectically.  
But that requires thinking outside-the-box.
Rick Simpson
Volunteer director, Oceola Fish & Game Club (OFGC), Lake Country; volunteer chair, OFGC fisheries committee; volunteer chair, Wood Lake Resort project environment oversight committee; volunteer director, BC Wildlife Federation Region 8 (Okanagan-Similkameen basins); volunteer co-chair, BC Wildlife Federation Region 8 fisheries committee; volunteer co-chair, BC Wildlife Federation Region 8 First Nations committee; volunteer member, BC Wildlife Federation inland fisheries committee – January 31, 2008

Redd Doesn't Ramble Far Enough
I read with great interest your editorial Houston We Have a Problem (Redd Room Ramble, January/February 2008), and I must say "right on." However, as someone who has seen the problem coming for about forty years, and someone who can read the English language, my criticism is that, number one, you did not use language that the average Joe Blow Sixpack can understand, and number two, you still talked around the subject. You, as I understand you, believe that the elephant in the room is world overpopulation: that there are just too many of us using the world's resources, especially if we all want the standard of living that North Americans and Europeans have; that at the present time, we are using up thirty per cent (30%) more of the planet's ecology every year than it can replace; that to get back to replacability, we would all have to scale back to a position where we would all be living at about a standard of that of the meanest third world economy, and thus the current population of about six and one-half billion is unsustainable. It is the technology, the tools that we have learned to make and use, and our over-use of energy and resources that has allowed us this unbridled growth of population. This is a position that I have held for over forty years and for it I have been roundly excoriated, called every sort of radical, lunatic and nut-case.

If, as I believe, this is what you were driving at in your editorial, then you must say so in language that the average person can understand and you must not just allude to the disaster that is coming due to our nonsense of believing that uncontrolled growth in the economies of the world, and in world population, but you must say so in understanable four letter words that everyone can understand, and you must say so forthrightly, not talking around the subject and being politically correct. It is just that, which has gotten us all into this mess; we must not hurt anyone's feelings; everyone must feel good. This is not a feel good subject and it is deadly serious. It is so serious that I frankly don't believe that we are anywhere in time to do any good; that nature will take care of the problem for us and it will not be pretty.

David Suzuki, Al Gore and a host of others have made an industry out of talking around what we must do, but I'm afraid that getting rid of the automobile, re-cycling, smokestack scrubbers and all of the other "solutions" that are talked about by the "Granola Crowd" are just feel good little thingees that every one would like to think are going to help, but they are just little feel goods. There is no such thing as sustainable growth, either in the economy or in population. The one thing that may help, before nature does it for us, is first, zero-population growth, RIGHT NOW, then second, begin reducing the worlds population down to at least pre-WW1 levels. Then perhaps the planet stands a chance, but really only likely a slim chance. I think that in our lifetimes, certainly in yours as I am quite alot older than you, we will see some pretty brutal changes coming.

If we want to mitigate these ugly changes, we are going to have to all get on board with such things as banning all unnecessary use of the internal combustion engine. By that, I mean all recreational uses: boats, ATVs, ski-doos, auto-racing and a host of others. We will have to get on board (and here I know I will hear all sorts of screams) with population reduction: allowing those that are born with no chance of a normal life, or to be able to look after themselves, to expire naturally; allow those elderly who are unable to survive without extraordinary means to expire naturally. This, I know, sounds draconian, but if we do not take measures then nature will do so and it may mean the end of all life, as we know it, on earth. It would be a shame if we were the cause of the demise of this lovely planet.

Thank you for your time. I must repeat, I did enjoy your editorial and realize that if you went as far as I just did that there would be no way that you could have printed it or on the other hand, you would likely have been drawn and quartered.
Vern – January 26, 2008

Kudos for Karen – Hospitals Count on Caring Kids
Thank you for the great article Karen (Slivar) – we can all be very proud of each of the many kids who volunteer in health care areas in the Okanagan – they are our future! Again, thanks for the terrific job of featuring Sunny (Gakhal) and Tony (Sam) from our program.
Candis Eikerman,
Manager Volunteer Services, North Okanagan Interior Health – January 22, 2008

Future Shock Sparks Interest
I just found a copy of the magazine, and it's GREAT! Thanks so much  for your coverage of the conference (Building Sustainable Communities - November 2007, Kelowna), it was really well done. I'm also  enjoying the Future Shock article, which will certainly get people thinking.
Joanne deVries, CEO, Fresh Outlook Foundation – January 21, 2008

More on Teens Count Too
Just a quick note to say thank you for your story regarding Teens Count Too. I was excited to read about Teens Count Too in your November/December 2007 issue! I was one of the three ladies who started this charity, and I feel privileged that our efforts are continued, and growing every year! Thank you for the recognition!!
Deborah Steffens – January 15, 2008

Charity of Choice Helps Cheer Teen Christmas
I was flipping through Okanagan Life yesterday and I came across your article about Teens Count Too. As Promotions Coordinator at Sun FM I was heavily involved in campaigning for Teens through the station. We raised a little over $17,000 this year during our annual fundraiser, I believe that's a record to date. Thank you for the extra publicity and your support!
Erin Setch - December 18

Special Olympics Athlete Coverage Appreciated
Just wanted to say thank you for covering our two athletes (John Bartram and Glen McIntyre) that went to Shanghai (Special Olympics Summer World Games). Loved the format that you took with them. I sent both pieces to our provincial office in Burnably. Thanks again as we really appreciate the support from your magazine. Next journey - 96 BC athletes to Quebec City in February (22 from the Okanagan for the Special Olympics Winter Games - Nationals).
Leslie Thornley - December 14

Reader Rave - Loves Cannings Story and More...
I am continually impressed with your magazine. Not only are there great photos but excellent editorial. In the current edition I particularly enjoyed the short bit on Dick Cannings.......too bad it wasn't a bit longer so more people could read about Dick, his knowledge, accomplishments and his interesting family. You may or may not know that Dick's father was honoured by citizens of Penticton as one of the 10 most influential citizens of Penticton in a Penticton Herald Poll earlier this year.
The other interesting article was the SPCA Pet Cemetary that we have here. As a matter of fact that cemetary is my "neighbour". My morning walk takes me there every day.
After reading the article on the National Park I subscribed to Okanagan Life and have just renewed my subscription. Congratulations on your continual excellent publications. I look forward to more.
Doreen Olson - November 30

Kudos for Cannings Stand on National Park
Thanks for the engaging profile of Dick Cannings. Naturalists throughout BC cherish him as a national treasure and those of us in the Okanagan are proud he's one of our own. The statement of support from Dick for the national park proposal is thankfully received. We thank Dick for saying it and you for publishing it.
Dennis St. John - November 28

Hurray for Heritage
...I must admit that I had not purchased a copy of your magazine before today, but having read the October edition, I am most impressed, and particularly about the theme of heritage being the feature in this edition. I also work for the Central Okanagan Heritage Society in Kelowna and will be passing this magazine around. It is so refreshing to see that finally heritage is getting the attention it deserves - I hope that people get a sense of what they can do with a heritage building from your articles, and that they appreciate what will be lost if we continue to knock it down. Adaptive reuse of heritage buildings, raising public awareness of the Okanagan's heritage treasures and preserving and restoring what is left are issues high on the priority list of the Central Okanagan Heritage Society. Thank you for your support of heritage.
Samantha Poling - November 19

Oops - Goof on Peachland Incorporation Date
I enjoyed your October issue very much. As you know, the history of our valley is a subject dear to my heart!
On page 21, column two, it was stated "Peachland was incorporated in 1899." In fact, Peachland was incorporated early in 1909 - with the first meeting of Peachland Council held in February 1909.
Dorothy Zoellner - October 30

Editor's Note: Thanks, Dorothy, for pointing out our error. You're right - Peachland was founded in 1899, but not incorporated until 1909.

Kudos for Our Content
I have come to realize and appreciate the wonderful content and diversity that Okanagan Life depicts with each new edition. Not many local publishers can come close to delivering the quality of reading that your staff is able to produce on a continued basis. I am truly grateful for the nine issues that are produced annually and for the community interests and intrigue that is shared so abundantly. Kudos to all, as you endeavour to share our community at large.
su knorr - October 29

"Who's Your Daddy" Strikes a Chord
I am the guy that called you (Luke) this morning after having read your article in the Okanagan Life magazine which was delivered to our door at work yesterday. First of all, I commend you for bearing your soul in print - especially about a subject so intimate and somehow controversial to say the least. I applaud you. My story in some ways parallels your's but in one way is still distintly different. I could really relate to you with some of the feelings you shared about your identity and the wondering of just who you are in this world. This is a bit of my story.
I was born in Edmonton, Alberta on April 15, 1953 and a month after my birth was surrendered for adoption. In October of that same year, my adoptive parents who were from Lacombe, Alberta, a small farming community some two hours south of Edmonton, took me home to be their first child. They had been married in 1951 but for whatever reason, were just not able to have a child so after a lot of thought and I'm sure, prayer, decided to apply to have a child through adoption. I grew up in a very stable, fundamental evangelical home (as in those days, when adopting a child, the parents were made to promise that they would take their children to church).
I was loved and very much wanted by my adopted parents. A year after my birth, my mother got pregnant - which often happens!!! So my sister was born in September of 1954 and my adoption was still not finalized due to some medical problems I had at birth. Once the problems were addressed, both through surgery and the other simply correcting itself, the adoption papers were signed in the spring of 1955. I was just one month short of being two years of age when the adoption was finally finished.
Shortly after my sister's birth, my adopted father began to have medical problems - a lump appeared on his thigh and was removed, only to find out it was benign. Then a year or so later, another growth appeared, was operated on and was found to be cancerous. We lived on a farm and over the next few years he was in and out of hospital in Edmonton, undergoing treatments for his cancer but eventually the disease was so rampant in his body that in 1963 they were forced to sell the farm and move into town. Less than a year later he died at the age of 43. I was just two months shy of my 11th birthday so by the time I was 11 I had already lost three parents.
My mother, three years later, picked up, left Lacombe with two kids and moved to Kelowna - the land of milk and honey and a place where we had come on holidays and where my father would have loved to live if he would ever be healed from cancer.
All my life I wanted to know who my birth parents were and I searched for 25 years, finding out tidbits of information here and there but always ending in a slammed door, usually just when I thought I was getting somewhere! It wasn't until I was 42 years old, some 12 years ago now, that the laws in the Province Of Alberta changed and I was finally able to hire a Search Agent to help me in finding my family. He would go to the Provincial Government, obtain the sealed adoption record, get a first hand look at names etc. and try to locate them. If the birthparents were willing to allow me to know who they were, the Government would release all the information to me and arrange a meeting with them.
In just three weeks, the Search Agent found the family I had been looking for for 25 years. I remember so well the Sunday afternoon in November that I got the call from the Search Agent informing me that he had found my family and they were willing for me to know who they were. The only sad news in all of it was that my birth mother had died - at the age of 55 - 20 years before - in 1975, just one month after I had been married. It turned out that my birth mother was a married woman and the rest of the story gets really muddled!!!!!
I won't bore you with all the details of that right now but I would love to get together with you sometime and share our stories with each other if you are willing to do that. I have endured a lot of emotional pain over the years because of not having a father in my life and then also when finding my birth family, there being a question as to who my birth father really is. A long story which I would love to share with you sometime.
Anyway, Luke, I just wanted you to know that you are not alone in your seach for peace in your life regarding your father. I still struggle with my identity, questions about the past that I cannot find answers to so I know in part where you are at.
...Thanks for the ear and again, thanks for the article. It is great and I am sure it has stirred the hearts of many.
Kerry Heidebrecht - October 17

Forthright Feedback
First the good.....your Red Room Ramble and the Help Wanted feature was a great read! I like that OL has opinion. Too much fluffy half baked wishy-washy smalltime media in this town. OL has some teeth, which is good to see. Your RRR page showed even more teeth, careful though, people will be getting pissed at you, hope you have broad shoulders buddy. But to the point, you describe succinctly exactly "how it is" in the town.
Keep up the challenging diverse features, it's making OL into something very interesting. We need more "different" in this town, there's too much of the same old same old.
And more of the good-and some bad....absolutely awesome feature on Silver Star and downhill mountain biking in general. The article communicated to a readership who are sport-unfamiliar group (non- mountain-bike-riders) exactly what mountain biking is about, and the fun, excitement, dangers, and challenge associated with the sport. I loved that you had the feature done by a female rider, great call. Myself and my wife ride downhill and freeride, and it's hard to get female riders into the harder edged scene, lots of machismo, etc, so to get exposure for female riders is welcomed. We personally work to ensure we have mixed group riding, with mixed skill and experience levels, and we have introduced new riders to the sport, so it's good to see that approach represented by OL.
Two points:
1) It seemed generally to be like an ad-feature for Silver Star, you mentioned Crawford but we have Gillard and Powers, two of the best freeride areas in the Interior. From this point, the timing was weird. Silver Star is now closed, this article should be been out in print in July ! Who's going to 'act on impulse' (i.e. to go rip the trails at Silver Star) having just read your article ? Also a few words from Steve Romaniuk, Ryan Scnepf, would back up the feature with some local celeb cred.
2) The page 73 cartoon was awful. Seriously. You put all that effort into producing a great article, professionally presented, and with the female rider angle too. Then ruin it by including what I think is an unfunny, crappy, low grade carton that (in the words of my wife, a female mountain biker) was 'insulting to women riders, not funny and just dumb'. Female riders have to put up with a whole bunch of barriers, psychological and physical, the cartoon was just crap.
Keep up the good work, OL is definitely progressing and we very much look forward to our copy each month.
Rich & Nicky Deakin - September 12

Red Room Ramble Riles Reader
I just read your column in this month’s issue of OK Life, and was quite disappointed to read your reference to a used car salesman/ polished lemon/talking out of his butt etc. Perhaps you didn’t know that car salespeople these days hold certified licenses, which they pay handsomely for, and, by the way, if you have paid any attention to the majority of your advertisement clientele it looks very automobile industry supported. You might want to think twice about slandering an industry of which obviously gives your profession so much support.
Brenda Massey-Bokitch - September 12

Editor's Note: It was not my intention to slander a whole industry or group of professionals. I have been treated well at reputable car dealerships to be sure. However, I have had personal experience purchasing what turned out to be a good-looking lemon from someone I thought was acting professionally. There are many cases of this happening through less- reputable/less-upstanding used car lots that sell only used vehicles (often times selling them illegally after being "restored" from major water or accident damage). I realize that used cars sales have come a long way in terms of more consumer-protective regulations and methods, but the salesman I am referring to in my tongue-in-cheek/sarcastic column is obviously one of the still- existing people of disrepute. I apologize if I offended you. Perhaps I was too cliché in my writing. I'll watch out for that in future columns. Thank you for the feedback!

ALR Architect Speaks Out -
Former BC Premier Dave Barrett called in and made these comments
I’m really impressed with the wonderful article that you’ve written about the ALR and I just wanted to chat with you briefly about a couple of other aspects of it. You’ve done a great service in keeping that program alert in the public’s mind. … especially brave in the Social Credit turf.

W.A.C. Bennett attacked us as dangerous communists over the ALR. You can go back and read some of that hysterical stuff and it came not only from Bennett senior, but later on when Bennett junior became premier. They were sniffing around trying to kill the ALR, but he backed off.

Campbell is now the one who is deliberately setting up these native Indian settlements as a precursor of getting other land out of the ALR. (Speaking about the Tsawassen deal) … this is just the beginning of opening the door, using the tragic situations with many of the First Nations people, as an opening to get the rest of the stuff out.

The other issue is that, in the Fraser Valley, where they took some land out of the ALR, they named one of the owners of the land onto a regional board for the ALR. Now they’ve set up a different structure. We had a board of professionals, not politicals and it was province wide.
You’ve hit the button in some of the other things you’re saying in the article – of the dangers that are there. There are more dangers than anyone else is really focussing on. People are feeling so good, everybody’s got jobs and the environment is not a single issue for a hell of a lot of people. But it is true that they’ve been pulling land out like crazy and dumping in garbage land and saying, oh, we’ve got more acreage.

So yours is the only article I’ve seen that’s given a précis of the history, without taking any sides, and just explained what happened, what’s going on and everything else.

…The years before we got in government, it was farmers themselves and ecologists who had been advocating, non-politically, for preservation of the land and the real guy in the caucus who picked it up was Stupich, he was the minister of finance later on, but he also had a degree in agriculture. Anyway, it all started there.

We had a bit of a tussle in the caucus, but in the end it became so bloody obvious in terms of what we’ve got and what we can lose that I said, to hell with it, let’s do it.… This is an incredibly beautiful place in the world – and the insensitivity – never mind whether you’re left-wing or right-wing or anything else, just the common sense about what we have and what future generations will scream bloody murder if they don’t have the same thing – is now being threatened by the current government….

But anyway, what you’re doing as a journalist is so wonderful and so important….
Thanks very much for writing in a logical, cautious manner with the exact figures, and demonstrating to people who want to think about it that there is a frightening train of events happening with the ALR.

Edmontonian Loves Okanagan Life Annual Valley Guide (Okanagan-Shuswap)
Kudos on one of the most beautiful magazines I have ever seen, the subject, the Okanagan, is dear to me. I was flipping through the issue that arrived at work and nearly cried when I saw Mount Bastion and the other Salmon Arm and Tappan scenes. I spent many summers
on Sunnybrae Road at my grandmother's home, she was originally a Dearing. In recent years I have been fortunate enought to visit more of the Valley and love every inch of it. The development and properity is nice to see, although it does bring many changes. Congrats on
a fine job and the talent you have on staff, especially Laurie Carter!
Laura Niven, Edmonton - August 13

Grant (Whiskey) Island - Keep Off
I have read your most recent magazine. There is one article was has caused some concern. The Article is entitled "Gunkholders delight". It concerns "Grant Island". As a Director of the Bishop Wild Bird Foundation which owns the island...there is a concern that the article is encouraging boaters to "visit" the island. As this is an important bird habitat we do not
want any visitation on the island.
Erin Nelson - July 26

Editor's Note: In the article, David Madison stated that the island is privately owned and that it is a bird sanctuary. We urge boaters to respect this and stay clear.

Reader Sends Okanagan Life to Toronto Mayor
In regards to your recent edition of Okanagan Life - you have to be congratulated - especially re: land fills. We can be very proud of our contribution to disposing of garbage - albeit still a ways to go. Flying over Toronto two years ago - I tried to imagine the amount of garbage collected in one day!! I wrote to the mayor and sent info re: our waste management and how proud we are of same. "He?" replied, saying they were aware but not many solutions at that time. I am sending your recent edition of O.K. Life to him and his councillors. "Toronto the Great" can start setting examples as well and it may spread.
You have an excellent staff - keep up the good work. We have a great deal to be proud of here in Kelowna - am hoping it will remain so.
Elsie (Couldn't read last name on signature) - July 18

Farmer Speaks Out
It was with great interest I read the latest issue of Okanagan Life. My husband and I purchased a 33 acre farm two years ago in Spallumcheen just outside of Vernon/Armstrong. We focus on specialty, heritage and hard to find produce. We both come from a strong hospitality background and approach farming with what we feel is a unique perspective on the customers needs and wants.
With all the focus on organics these days, I feel that the conventional farms are viewed by the general population as not responsible to our consumers. This couldn't be farther from the truth. Yes we do use sprays on our farm as do some organic farms do as well.....the organics have sprays/fertilizers etc..that are approved by the organic associations...are they better? Well....I guess you be the judge. I also realize there are more puritan organic farms that use nothing at all. However nitrogen is nitrogen whether it comes from manure or a fertilizer bag..... I tell ya with nine acres of baby carrots, 12 acres of specialty beets, eight acres of asparagus , a variety of heritage and heirloom products and five acres of heirloom tomatoes the hand processing of all bugs, weeds would be a staggering cost to both the plants themselves and $$ to the consumer. So many of the products rely on weed free fields to germinate properly and with large wholesale contracts to fill there has to be a way to give the products a fighting chance. Are we responsible...ABSOLUTELY...we pay attention to days to harvest, the utmost of sanitation procedures and fully confident in our products that leave our farm. Are there some farms that aren't....sure just as in any industry it pays to get to know the person providing your family with any goods or services.
We are also involved with the Canadian Horticultural Society with a food safety program. It shows documentation of processes and is a good basis to having a food safe farm.
I in no way think your article was biased to conventional farming, just wanted to say a little on behalf our little plot of land!
We have considered organic farming...maybe one day....for now this is the route we have chosen and have been enjoying the change in our life as we take on this latest endeavor.
Jen Bellmann - July 14

ALR Story Elicits Thoughtful Response
May I congratulate you on a well presented article in your June issue regarding the Agricultural Land Reserve versus the need for land for residential space. In a province of 366,000 sq. miles with only five percent arable land, of which much has been lost already to development, one can appreciate the angst of those that have to make decisions as to what must remain in the ALR and what can be released.
From the point of view of the farmer/orchardist who has seen diminishing returns from his efforts and has reached that point in life where he is too tire, or financially unable, to upgrade his holdings and looks upon them as his retirement fund, one can only feel sympathy. Further there are undoubtedly areas in the ALR where it would be a challenge to grow turnips and make a profit.
Conversely, the pressure is on to make available living space at a reasonable price for those wanting to make the Okanagan their home. There is no doubt that the high cost of residential accomodation has detered many younger families from locating here. (Apparently members of the RCMP have declined transfers to the Okanagan, with thanks, due to the high cost of real estate).
If I recall correctly, there was an experiment tried on Vancouver Island in the Cowichan Valley area, whereby arrangements were made for a younger person to take over some of the dairy farms and tend them. This was some years ago so I don't recall the details. Surely there must be an acceptable solution to saving the agricultural land, even if it means the province purchasing the land and leasing it to younger people eager to try their hand at tilling the soil. Expecting California, with its expanding population, to keep us supplied is both reckless and insane showing a complete lack of responsibility.
David A. B. Hall - July 6

More Kudos for Agriculture/Land Use Stories
Thank you for a very informative and interesting series of articles in the past Okanagan Life.
I think it is great that you have taken the time to research several very important issues for our valley and our world. It is helpful to see what other communities are doing and how we each can help in our own areas. I love the idea of "pairing up" with a farmer so he can grow his food with assurance! Even the garbage aticle was interstingly written and an interesting topic. Hats off to your crew - obviously not just a bit of fluff!
Lynne Smith - June 26

Something to Think About
Okanagan Life magazine has given me considerable reading enjoyment over the ten years I have lived in the area. I have never been moved towards letter writing to media sources but have simply taken most of what I see and hear for granted. Until now, that is. I realized suddenly that there has been a shift in editorial policy at Okanagan Life which has perked up my senses and I have been re-reading a few of the latest issues.
Issues would seem to be a key word. Your magazine has morphed into a source of knowledge about our community that grabs at people’s imagination and creates discussion. A far cry from the bland little country stories we were accustomed to reading.
There are enough bland media about. It takes real courage to present the public with issues they can debate. Keep up the good work.
James G. White - June 26

Conservation Cop - Madison "Gets" His Man
This massage is for David Madison. On behalf of my family and I, I would just like to say thank you. Thank you for the amazing article you wrote about my father, he is an amazing,
hard working man and deserves all the recognition. In his job he does not get a lot of thank you's, he gets more grief then anything. Your article delves into the man he really is and
that is the best thank you of all. Reading your words brought tears to my eyes, cause I am just so proud of him, knowing how hard both he and Ed Seitz work. You captured his spirit, his integrity, his love for what he does. This job is not just a 9 to 5 for him.... that photo you took of him standing beside his truck. It captured him the way I always think of him.
Shawna Hoyer - June 19

Happiness on Colourful Front Street
Thank you Laurie Carter for the page 17 article on Front St. in June's Okanagan Life. So well written that the rest of the restaurants and stores not mentioned felt left over! Thank you again.
Writer prefers not to be identified online - June 19, 2007

Editors' Pic Puts Annie's on the Map
Please forward this heartfelt thank you to all. As one of your first annual editors' picks you have made me a celebrity in my home town!! And you have helped put my little store on the map! We have customers coming in daily saying they read about us in your magazine. The photographer did an oustanding job...even my mouth waters when I look at the picture. Your writer labelled us bang on...you never know what you will walk into in my store! Again, many thanks for acknowledging Cantaloupe Annie's...drop in whenever you're in town or passing through.
Jane MacFadden - June 19

Kudos for Land Use Issue
I received my copy of Okanagan Life in the Cap News (I’m over in the Shannon Lake area) and I just wanted to thank you. I thought it was absolutely fantastic. A lot of people, especially younger people, have been fretting and worrying about farmland now. I think it’s a fantastic sign of the times (literally on the cover, there). I live where that sign is on that piece of land. I was just absolutely thrilled to see this issue. I think it’s really important. I wouldn’t mind having a few extra copies to give to the occasional person.
I wrote a piece on the garbage issue for a website some time ago and I think everybody should be forced to go look at the landfill once in a while.
It was a significant issue with significant stories and I think it’ll have a ripple effect for a long time. So I wanted to say thank you.
Deborah Greaves – June 18

More Restaurant Info
Hey Guys - come on! What were you thinking!
I am a subscriber and received the May issue last week. In your extensive, and beautifully presented EDITORS CHOICE AWARDS: Who did you have in mind - as your reader?
No hard facts. No addresses. No telephone numbers. In most of the cases - no mention of the town or location. How does someone find the places you chose........by looking
each one up via Google, and finding (hopefully) a website?
Did you ever put yourselves in the place of the reader who is NOT a resident of the Okanagan? Obviously not.
If this is an "Insider's Guide" for residents already living in the Okanagan, who know all of these places - then fine. But for me, a Vancouver resident who subscribed for the sole purpose of receiving this issue and to be introduced to the Okanagan for travel purposes - this issue loses on all points.
As for your next section READERS CHOICE AWARDS - again you get by with categorizing the choices as "North" "Central" and "South." Again, who did you have in mind as your reader? It is purely an "Insider's Guide." No clue as to how to find these listings. No hard facts. No addresses. No telephone numbers. No towns named. Then I thought.......maybe the restaurants named in the issue had placed ADS - and that is how we could find the locations, etc. But, alas, this was not the case.
I have never seen an editorial issue such as this - featuring restaurants - with nothing for a visitor to the region to go on.
I am sorry I subscribed.
Edena Sheldon - May 24

Editor's Note: Since the overwhelming majority of our readers are Okanagan residents, we do write for an audience with a certain local knowledge. Among the Editors' Choice picks, all but two stories stated the location city and several mentioned the street as well. As for the Readers' Choice Awards, location is provided in brackets for restaurants outside the major centres for the region. Otherwise, local readers would know the cities - Vernon for the North, Kelowna for Central and Penticton for the South. In both cases, we felt that listing addresses and phone numbers could leave the impression that these were paid advertisements and we want no confusion on that score.

Where's the Fish
Hello from Port Albernie. I formerly resided in Kelowna and always enjoyed your magazine. My query is - I would like to read the article about Shady Rest Fish and Chips (the best) but couldn't locate on web page. Believe or not I have been unable to find good fish and chips here where the fish is caught. Go figure. Would appreciate if you can be of help.
Eleanor Schoenenberger - May 14

Editor's Note: Click here to download the full Editors' Choice section available on our Feature Story page.

Hate the Reviews
I was insensed enough to contact you because of your rediculous artices by Laurie Carter. The others gave information about and a reason to visit their subjects.
Pg. 18 Hoang Gia. All about her, Very little description of the food or the decor and the popularity. Should have told about how crowded with men this place is at lunch time and about how popular their huge bowls of soup are.
Pg. 19 Greek House. The resraurant name doesn't appear until the last paragraph. Only 8 - 2" lines about food. The wonderful flavors and large servings should take up most of the article.
Pg. 22. Fresco. More cutesy about her fantisy
Pg. 28 Lost Moose Lodge. another fantisy instead being about their food.
Pg. 38 Siam Orchid. The picture shows food but the article tells nothing about the wonderful flavors and larger than usual servings that would draw in first timers.,
Pg. 42 Kelly O'bryan's. This was the worst one. The whole article was about her fantisy of looking up the waiter's skirt. If it was a waitress this article would have been politically incorrect. There was nothing about what foods they serve ar the atmosphere.
Joan Chickloski - May 14

Love the Photos
I just received the new May edition of Ok Life... and as a photographer myself... I am sooo impressed with the photographs for the entire "best restuarants" section. I think they are
the best photos I have ever seen in your magazine... kudos to Lillie Louise Major!
Maria O'Neil - May 11

Sex and the Valley
thanks you so much for the excellent job you (Shelley Wood) did on the article about school district 23's family life program. It was accurate and well written and I really appreciate that.
Laura Grenda - April 25

Our New Look
I am totally impressed with the evolution of the magazine in all its transformations from graphic design to the excellent (journalistic) articles coming out. Kudos to you, Paul and all
the staff for doing such good work.
Dorothy Zunti - April 21

Crime in the Valley
I would like to commend you on the March edition titled Crime in the Valley. I think the articles presented were well balanced and exposed all sides of the issue. This exposé will go a long way to help people become more knowledgeable and informed about crime and what resources are available.
Having lived in Kelowna since 1978, I am aware that many people in this area prefer to bury their head in the sand and don't want to admit that as we grow we will start to have big city problems. I don't feel that the answer is to be afraid and stay out of the downtown area. On the contrary I think we should spend more time down there as criminals don't want to be observed. They want to be hidden.
I thought the final article called "It's the Minor Misdeeds" was a great way to conclude. I fully agree that we as parents, grandparents and a community as a whole, have a great responsibility to support our children and young people to develop into competent and valuable citizens. Some times it is the small one-time bits of advise and coaching that have the lasting impact.
Prevention is much cheaper and more long-lasting than dealing only with the fallout when good people do bad things. I would like to suggest that you do a follow-up edition on ways the community, professionals, parents and grandparents can make a difference with our youth.
Thank you once again for your efforts.
Natalie Wheatley - March 11

Special Olympics Winter Games
WOW! What a great article covering the upcoming Special Olympics Winter Games in Kelowna!
Linda Galpin - January 29

Less Snow, More Woe - Comeback
The object of the global warming snow article was to be objective about what is the true reality of the situation (yes--global warming is happening) and the awareness Valley people have about it. It's pretty low! How I feel about snow is irrelevent.
If the urgency of the global warming situation was not conveyed, I believe it is in the view of the reader. If enough people don't do enough to personally combat this real issue, we are going to be in a dire situation.
Dona Sturmanis - January 11

Less Snow, More Woe
The article written by Dona Sturmanis in the Jan/Feb issue (Cold Disappearing Act)
left me breathless; not from admiration, but rather from rage. If I were being generous
than I would attribute Dona’s enthusiasm for global warming and its “positive” side
effects as mere ignorance, but it reads as astounding selfishness. Sure you might
have warmer weather to play golf, but how are you going to keep the greens green when the
water supply diminishes? And won’t all those troublesome forest fires put you off your
putt? Not to mention the lack of trees caused by pine beetle that is rampant because of the
lack of freezing temperatures.
We are very lucky people to live in the Okanagan with its beautiful lake and rich ecosystem. As a magazine that celebrates the natural wonder of Okanagan Life, you should be encouraging people to cherish and help preserve it.
Shame on you Dona!
Georgina Parton - January 10, 2007

Special Olympics
I was in the Okanagan for the past two days and got to see the magazine!!
It is sensational!! Thank you so much for all of the work you did on this
project. It is a truly wonderful piece on Special Olympics!!
Lois McNary - January 10

Special Olympics
The spread looks soooo amazing!
Thank you so much.
Heather Young
Manager, Communications
Special Olympics BC - January 10, 2007

New to the Valley - Loves Okanagan Life
Just wanted to congradulate you for the production of such a wonderful magazine, I moved to Kelowna from Edmonton and I truly love your magazine. Keep up the excellent work.
Marsha Guenette - January 3, 2007

Clash of the Conservationists
Battle lines over the proposed National Park are being drawn In many ways, the ideological battles being fought in the South Okanogan over the proposed establishment of a national park mirror the global state of affairs dealing with preserving wild lands. On the one hand, we are all awestruck going through Banff, Jasper, Cape Breton or the Pacific Rim National Parks and we thank those with the foresight to set these lands aside. On the other side are the challenges of setting aside large tracts of land that are currently used for grazing, recreational and commercial uses.
As the work has gone on to determine whether such a park is feasible, emotions have been stirred in the Okanogan communities. The urban centres of Penticton and Kelowna are generally supportive. The residents of the southern part of the valley, which will see a more direct impact on their lives, tend to have more mixed feelings towards the proposed park.
As the work continues the battle lines seem to be getting drawn. Conservationists are pitted against each other; neighbour against neighbour and the first nations are varied in their
support as well.
Some nations take up arms over such issues. In Canada, we talk.
Brian Hughes - December 21, 2006

Editor's Note: Click on Events for details on the upcoming Penticton Philosopher's Cafe with guest speakers Greg Norton, representing a diverse group who favour multiple use zones; Dick Cannings, well known biologist in favour of the National Park; and Jeanette Armstrong, Director of the En'owkin Centre, who will speak to the First Nations issues. The goal of the session is to heal the rifts and encourage understanding. January 25, 7:00 pm
En'owkin Centre on Green Mountain Rd.

Trucker Tackles Trains
I just read, with interest, David Madison's article on the two Shuswap/Okanagan railways in the June 2006 issue of OK Life. Living in the North Okanagan, high on the west side, we are very much aware of OVR activity. Their engine's horns sound at every intersection (usually in the dead of night when we hear them) as they 'centimetre' their way through our community on their travels between Kelowna and Sicamous.
Having spent over 50 years as a long-haul trucker, and the last 5 years in safety and compliance, related to the trucking industry, I am very much attuned to the so-called rivalry between the two modes of transportation. I am also a railroad buff and am in possession of quite an extensive library of rail literature. It was easy to become a fan of the rail as the Trans-Canada Highway pretty much parallels the CPR and the Yellowhead Highway follows the CNR, our nation's two major RRs and two major roadways.
Actually, the competition between rail and road is less than 20%. Trucks will always be used for time sensitive and most perishable freight hauling, and have the capability of delivering right to your door. There is a saying, "If you have it - a truck brought it!" In fact Canada's two major rail lines, the CPR and the CNR, own huge fleets of trucks which deliver freight to most points in the country, and many are seen daily in the Okanagan corridor. Thousands of kilkometres of rail lines have been abandoned over the years, so it stands to reason that as the population continues to explode, the dependency on truck delivery will also continue to expand. The market share for trucking is expected to rise by almost 15% by 2010, while both rail and marine traffic is expected to decline.
Environmentally, the two modes are even wider apart. Truck engines, which have a much shorter life expectancy than locomotive engines (about 5 years as opposed to around 40) have been strictly regulated since the early '80s. Truck engines also benefit from the very latest in technology and efficiency. Diesel fuel for trucks, for example, is currently limited to 15 ppm. (parts per million) of sulphur. Rail locomotives are still pumping out 3,000 ppm. and will continue to do so until after 2007, when they will be restricted to only 500 ppm. It doesn't take a Rhode's scholar to figure out that one diesel rail locomotive today, expels as much sulphur content into the air as 200 tractor-trailers. Sort of puts things into perspective.
All the above information is readily available to anyone, including Mr. Madison, who has the time and energy to research it.
Ed Murdoch - December 1, 2006

Best of the Okanagan
In your Editors'Choice section of the Nov/Dec edition, you have a category for "Best Scream-Inducing Dessert Wine," but the wine is an aperitif...check the dictionary.
Carmen St. Jean - November 28, 2006

Editor's Note: Silver Sage Winery, while calling it an aperitif on the bottle, also markets it heavily as a dessert wine. It is one of those odd products that can have multiple uses. See their website (http://www.silversagewinery.com/profiles.php) or visit them for a tasting.

Best of the Okanagan
Your editors' choices are far more useful than the readers' choice because they are more limited in scope and greater in detail. The best dry cleaner choice is not of any use, frankly, and neither are most of the categories although one always learns about a business not previously known. I think it would be more useful to profile the best of the new businesses as there are so many.
I wonder too about some of the voting. In the best antique shop category is Tutt Antiques. There is no Tutt antique store per se so I see how it can be included.
Your magazine is a pleasure to get although it is not always delivered in my neighbourhood.
Eve Foran - November 26, 2006

Editor's Note: Regarding Tutt Antiques - our readers voted and Tutt, whether a shop or simply an antique business, came second.

Best of the Okanagan
Just reading the Best of Edition, and noticed that you have the Enchanted Forest as one of the Best Atractions. Way to go, but one important omission was noticed - since the 80s, it has
been owned and run by the Ehlers Family. I think they deserve a lot of credit for the last 20 some odd years of additions!
Erin Scott - November 23, 2006

New Subscriber
I am so very impressed with the September and October issues of Okanagan Life that I bought a subscription. I loved the story about the "Green Knight" (Oct). Maryanne Wheeldon is quite the character. More people should follow her example or better still not throw trash anywhere but in the proper container. The Mascot Mine story was good too. I love the town of Hedley and wish them every success with their project. Your story will be helpful in getting them the profile they deserve.
. . . the National Park story. We really appreciated the balanced reporting.
Doreen Olsen - November 17, 2006

Proposed Park and Kudos
Thanks for the article, Clash of the Conservationists, as it provided some good insights into this issue. For our part, this is one of those issues in which compromise (not compensation) is not realistic when it comes to preserving the integrity/sustainability of endangered areas...consider the article in this weekends Capital News on the vandalism done in the Little White Mtn. area as an example of what occurs when strict rules and management oversight are not in place.
Some folks will be impacted and should be fairly compensated but the greater good of environmental sustainability should prevail. There exist huge tracks where development of every kind can occur (often with devastating impacts to ecology) so we must preserve what and as much as we can for once lost it is gone forever.
Kudos to your magazine for doing more than just promote a business development focus through the often typical "rose coloured glasses" approach of many other local publications. By biting into more controversial or thought provoking subject matter, such as "Clash..." you become a window for a much broader, more informed readership. Please continue this trend!
John & Barbara Waters - October 23, 2006

South Okanagan Similkameen National Park Reserve
Congratulations on what I feel is a very well balanced discussion of the many points of view on the national park. The prominence given the issue too is much appreciated. I hope more and more people continue to take an interest in the matter and attend open houses.
Eva Durance - October 23, 2006